Archives: Alana S.

You mean that chimp isn’t my kin after all?

Alana S. 07.30.2010 4:40 PM

Scientists and Darwin-enthusiasts are dedicating their entire careers and adult lives trying to uncover the truth of human ancestry as it dates back millions of years. Is it so outlandish that some of us demand to know the truth of our ancestry as it pertains to our immediate paternity?

Elaine Morgan explains how we’ve been misled about our ancestral lineage and it’s time to uncover the truth about our aquatic origin.


Elín and Alana. The Lesbian and The Donor Kid

Alana S. 07.27.2010 6:17 AM

My dear friend and band-mate, Elin Ey, agreed to sit down with me for an interview. Elin is a lesbian. I am devoted to restricting sperm and egg donation in America. Our friendship may seem to be in conflict.

I sadly do not have high quality recording equipment, but this 48 minute conversation may be just what you’re interested in listening to for your morning commute. I ask Elin what her goals for family planning were before she met me, and now- after the development of our friendship. Enjoy.

Elin’s music can be found on her myspace page. Or if you’re like me, and prefer to both hear and watch, go here for video.


The Kids Are Alright

Alana S. 07.22.2010 1:25 AM

Spoiler Alert: If you haven’t seen The Kids Are Alright yet, maybe you’d like to save this post for your Blackberry reading material on the ride home from the theater.

I saw a lot of myself in this film, even though the movie clearly focused on the struggles of the parents, rather than the kids (not necessarily a bad thing, adults’ stories have a right to exist).

Favorite quotes:

  • Jules (Julianne Moore): “The plan was to limit his involvement. I don’t want to timeshare our kids.”
  • Laser  (son)  to Paul (biological father): “Do you want to be buried or cremated?” Paul’s response: “Buried! I don’t want to be diminished into a white creamy substance.” Laser: “What does it matter? You’ll be dead anyways…” Paul: “Yea, but I would want some place for my family to come visit me.”
  • Joni (daughter): “I got all A’s. I did everything you wanted so now you can show to everyone what a perfect lesbian family you are.”

Points to Appreciate:

  • Sexuality can be complicated and mixed. To cage people into categories of gay and straight and expect them to stay that way forever doesn’t express human sexual behavior justly. You may like strawberry ice-cream most days, but every now and then, its fun to taste a little rocky road- or watch someone else taste it on a big HD TV screen with surround sound.
  • Allowing your sperm donor to enter your social circle is messy and generally a bad idea- if you want to keep your marriage intact, don’t let him anywhere near your kids or your pretty wife.
  • Marriage is difficult. Managing a household with other human beings brings struggles even when you have love, cash, and straight-A kids.
  • Men, especially rugged, careless ones with a strong will to procreate, are not to be trusted. They will steal your woman and jeopardize the safety of your children.
  • You don’t always know what you’re getting. Just because Donor Dad said he was studying International Relations on that fill-in-the-blank questionnaire he submitted when he was 19, doesn’t mean he’s much of a brainiac. He may in fact, turn out to be a food-service slacker with no motivation to participate in team sports.
  • Your children will not grow up to be younger carbon copies of you nor your sperm donor.
  • If you’re a child of sperm donation, you have a choice. You can either seek out your biological father and try to cultivate a relationship with him, or you can maintain loyalty to the parent(s) that raised you. You can not do both simultaneously. Children must pick which parent to let in and love wholly because your social parent most likely will be significantly threatened by the involvement of your biological father.

Disappointments:

I craved further development of the kids’ characters. They brushed on what I felt were central developmental struggles for fatherless kids. Laser’s friend Clay was an example of masculinity run amok: an exceptionally immature, insensitive exhibitionist who got his jollies from skateboarding off roof-tops and urinating on the faces of feral dogs. I wish the point was made clearer that boys with no consistent usher into Manhood, will often separate from their mothers and shape their expression of masculinity in (self) destructive ways.

Joni, the daughter, is obviously having issues with sexuality. She is straight. She wants to go after a male acquaintance of hers, but has no idea how to. This concept was so shallowly touched upon, I have no real idea what the writers’ thoughts are on this subject- though I appreciate their acknowledging it at all. Which brings me to my favorite words from David Blankenhorn’s book, Fatherless America, a.k.a., Alana’s favorite book ever:

Pages 46-47

A father plays a distinctive role in shaping a daughter’s sexual style and her understanding of the male-female bond. A father’s love and involvement builds a daughter’s confidence in her own femininity and contributes to her sense that she is worth loving… Deprived of a stable relationship with a non-exploitative adult male who loves them, these girls can remain developmentally “stuck,” struggling with issues of security and trust that well-fathered girls have already successfully resolved.

He quotes Judith Musick:

The self’s voice in these young women may remain fixed on one basic set of questions… What do I need to do, and who do I need to be, to find a man who won’t abandon me, as the men in my life and my mother’s life have done? …Girls for whom basic acceptance and love are the primary motivating forces have little interest or emotional energy to invest in school or work-related activities unless they are exceptionally bright and talented. Even then, the pull of unmet affiliative or dependency needs may be more powerful than anything the worlds of school or work have to offer.

I plenty understand the limits of a screenplay. A writer only has 100 pages to say what they want to say. Every creator has to work within limitations and I appreciate the perspective of the mothers in this movie- important truths were told. I look forward to more art and media from a child’s perspective, focusing on development and growth, via their point-of-view.

There was only one point in the movie where I cried- Mark Ruffalo, bio-dad, fastens a helmet onto Joni’s head right before he takes her on a sunset ride through the LA basin on his motorcycle. He secures it onto her in a completely sweet moment of father-daughter gentleness and they smile at each other. For some reason the tears just started rolling. I was so envious of Joni in that moment, and not just because I love motorcycles. She was being invited and ushered into an epically joyful piece of masculine culture- and there was absolutely no sexual tension, no quid pro quo. She didn’t have to lead him on or sleep with him to bask in the joys of his masculine universe. That is what it means to be loved by your father.

On the affair:

I don’t feel prepared to assert any significant insights into the complicated entanglements of Jules and Paul’s affair and the great blur of sexuality and procreation. But I will say… the magnetic charge of a man is likely to increase if you make children with him. I found myself wishing desperately that Jules would break up with Nic to be with Paul. Oh how lucky Laser would be for the two people that made him to fall in love and get together. Of course, such a move would dismantle the entire micro-utopia Jules and Nic worked for so many years to create. So for person A and B to win, that means person C, D, and (B?) will have to lose. Someone always gets left out. And fathers just make things messy anyways.

Oy-vey.


Organ Harvesting

Alana S. 07.20.2010 9:43 AM

I was walking through Queens’ K-Town yesterday, the second largest Korean community in the US- I feel a connection to Korean culture since that is the country my parents bought my older sister from, before they knew about sperm donation…

I came across this table filled with brochures and horrific images set up by a small group of concerned citizens attempting to educate and spread awareness about an alarming human rights violation in China: government sponsored organ harvesting against the Falun Gong practitioners of mainland China.

On poster-board, they displayed a large image of a skinny young man sprawled lifeless on a cot- three, long, thick sutures branched out from where his heart would be- like the inner-filling of a peace sign, though peace was farthest from the conjured sentiment of the image. He was a Chinese Falun Gong practitioner, an officially de-humanized demographic- a voiceless, non-member of mainstream China.

The front page of the brochure I picked up illustrates the human body and displays the price point associated with each body part, if one is in the market for a particular type of human tissue…

Cornea: $30,000. Lung: $150-170,000. Kidney: $62,000. Liver: $98-130,000. Pancreas: $150,000. Heart: $130-160,ooo. The tag-line above the menu read, “Is the value of a human life… equal only to the sum of its parts?”

Do we do anything like that here in America?

I realize that my mom and her husband didn’t physically kill my father to exploit his “tissue” when creating me. And even though it hurt like hell when I sold my eggs, I did it consciously and voluntarily and I’m still here to talk about it. But violence or no violence, voluntarily or involuntarily, indeed what is the value of a human life? And if we don’t hold such a thing sacred, is there anything left at all to spare from the choke of capitalism?

Organ harvesting is an intense brand of human exploitation. In honor of that dead man on the table, may redemption come quick.


Birthdays

Alana S. 07.19.2010 8:29 PM

So this Friday I turned 24- an elegant number for what will hopefully be an elegant year. There were some choice details I’d like to share if I’m allowed. I feel like its appropriate to write about how I celebrated my birth, after I’ve been complaining about it so much…

First, the facebook notes ensued. I had long lost friends from all over the globe wish me a quick gefeliciteerd,  or grattis födelsedagen or a joyeuse anniversair- delightful in any language. Then the phone calls: close friends, Sister, Mom… “Happy birthday to you, happy birthday to you, happy birthday dear…” her song went. Mom’s voice, followed by my little brother’s delivered two separate “I love you’s” and “good-bye’s” (no step-dad in the audio-mix). When I was a kid I used to revel in imagery of my mom sacrificing her body, joy and resources for my soul benefit. I imagined her delivering me in a frightening hospital, with a stranger doctor invading her privacy as he tried to do his job. She would be pained and regretful. Then I would try to imagine how much money she’s spent on me in a lifetime. I thought of what seemed like a huge number, one thousand. I bet she’s spent at least one thousand dollars on me. I would always comment to her every birthday, “Mom, thank you so much for giving birth to me.” This year I didn’t say those words. I chose to rephrase my gratitude. Instead, I said, “Mom, thanks for loving me and giving me so much of yourself.”

It’s not that I’m ungrateful for an array of precious moments my life has privileged me to; it’s just that I’m not sure life and birth in itself deserves celebration, but rather, the successful delivery and development of a life force: human energy.

I joke with one of our readers, Dawn, who once made the comment, “I don’t understand why donor kids don’t just go out and enjoy life more- like go to the beach!” I understand her point, it often accompanies the ever-so-common question from anyone and everyone who was not donor-conceived, “so you’re saying you wish you’d never been born?” Which places me in a position where I’m forced to measure and weigh my positive vs. negative life experiences and make a judgment call to total strangers about whether or not my life itself has been worth living.

I don’t know how I pulled it off, but this year’s birthday party added mega points into the “worth it” bucket. Bare with me, I’m about to brag a little. We converted my garden-backyard into a performance stage and invited Brooklyn’s finest to celebrate my existence with music, cake, and freshly bloomed sunflowers. Jenny Wilson, pretty much one of my favorite musicians of all time, not yet well-known in the US, but one of Sweden’s A-list female performers, somehow wandered into my party and gave us an unexpected, and much cherished performance.

I bonded with her on my shared Swedish roots- so thankful to have the real stories of my ancestors from my mom’s side. It makes bonding with my favorite Swedish Indie-pop stars so much easier. “How do you speak any Swedish?” she asked. “Well… my family founded this town called Swedeborg see…” I talked about going to the cobble-stone pier in Göteborg, where 90% of all Swedish immigrants boarded and left for America. I talked about what a mistake my ancestors made in immigrating- if they had only stayed I wouldn’t have to sell precious items like my guitar or my eggs just to get a little dental work every so often.

It’s so nice to know where you come from. It’s so nice to know who you come from. For times like this very special birthday I just experienced, when feelings of isolation disappear and connections are made with people I respect and admire, the bucket tips and it becomes worth it.

But what about all the Polish pop stars I’m not bonding with because of my ignorance of that other half of me!


The key is commitment.

Alana S. 07.17.2010 6:39 PM

Dan Gilbert gives a speech on happiness at Ted.com.

Freedom to choose is the end of synthetic happiness

On marriage: For folks who enter a marriage thinking, “well if it goes wrong and I decide I don’t like them anymore, I can always get a divorce and find someone better…” Will they really be happier? Probably not. It seems for those of us who are “stuck” with something (or someone) we make the best of what we’ve been given, find the poetry, and learn to love it. Because we have to.

I got in a heated debate yesterday with my four roommates (all around 24, typical middle-class white kids interested in the arts). “I wish my parents had gotten a divorce” one said, “they would have been so much happier apart.” But would they have been? Would the split in financial security, the constant schlepping of children, and the scary search for a new someone really have been a trade up? Where does happiness come from? Is love instant? If it comes fast and swift can’t it be taken away just as quickly? Do we cultivate it? Does it thrive through attention? Do we attach ourselves to that one someone or that one idea, feed it, nurture it, and watch it develop through time and dedication?

If society tells us its okay to quit and start over, as often as we’d like- constantly trading up for better features, a newer model, are we being taught a raw lesson?

The key is commitment.

And as far as donor conception goes: parents, that shiny new kid ain’t gonna make you happy. Happiness is like an orgasm. You can’t expect someone else to provide one for you. You’re responsible for your own.


Contradictions

Alana S. 07.15.2010 7:30 AM

The family reunion has gone and past and I’m back in Brooklyn, trying to make sense of my time there. This trip was particularly stressful because I decided that I was going to finally tell my mom about all the work I’ve been doing in opposition to commercial conception. She knows that I’ve spent the last year and a half writing the script and assembling a team for a film about my sperm-donor father. She didn’t know it was critical of her decision to have me this way. She didn’t know I was blogging and interviewing about it. The conversation didn’t go so well. Read More


Joyless Parenting

Alana S. 07.12.2010 3:51 PM

having a baby has stopped being an inevitable part of the life cycle and started to be one of those things-to-do-before-you-die, like climbing Machu Picchu or running a marathon.

Gwynne Watkin’s op-ed on Joyless Parenting. We’ve become accessories, trophies to our parents. Our charms and abilities are quantifiable and marketable indicators of the superior genes and management skills of our mom(s) and dad(s). When people become items to be procured, do we get buyer’s remorse when the hell-raisers don’t play to our expectations? Can we go to customer service and get a refund?


Family Reunion

Alana S. 07.04.2010 9:30 AM

I’m in Lake of the Ozarks- retreating to bed after a long day with my matrilineal kin. The contrast between here and my home in Brooklyn is vivid. In this modest section of central Missouri you’ll find a lot of churches, a lot of cattle, and a lot of rusty old barns. Here, adult super-store billboards memetically compete with bible passages for interstate highway ad space and if you don’t go to church, chances are you’re a meth addict. Successful men here either start their own farming business, or climb the ranks of the military. Beauty is an adjective confined to children, for by age 12 most people have ballooned into obesity or failed to meet even substandard grooming expectations. For anyone without family ties to this area, it would seem like a bleak hell-hole: a web of dysfunctional systems unintelligibly constructed by a sparse community of well-meaning, but incompetent country folk. This is where my mom grew up. These are the people I call family.

At our reunion, my mom, step-dad, brother and I are the only ones who live outside the region. Entering adulthood, my mother chose to escape to paradise after paradise, Read More


How to Procure a First Choice Family

Alana S. 06.28.2010 1:48 PM

I shared a milkshake two nights ago at a midtown diner with a new friend who invited me out for a discussion- on marriage, family planning, and the causes and implications of the new trend of delayed marriage in America.

One of the big questions was: Why are we waiting so much longer to start our families? Some would say its a prolonging of childhood and a generation of perpetual kids that can’t or won’t grow up. But what does it mean to be a grown up? Is it important to identify as such a creature before attempting to raise your own  hellion or two?

My new friend asked me, “Alana, what do you need to have in place before you start a family?” My answer:

  1. A father for the kid.
  2. Some money.

Attracting a suitor is not a main reason for the delay in marriages- even our most charmless sisters and brothers are bringing a warm body home tonight to cuddle with. But this question of money: when the average American has a negative savings rate at .5%, are we delaying marriage because we’re bank beat and broke?

Probably.

This concerns me mainly because a huge number of women are seeking out egg donation services because they’ve waited into their 30’s, 40’s, and yes, 50’s to have children. They’re spending gobs of cash for younger women’s eggs (who are selling because they’re desperate for money), when what they really want is their own eggs, and to keep their money. What is different? Why do our women feel the need to wait so long to the point of infertility before they feel prepared for motherhood?

I spent my summer in Iceland and I was shocked at the number of beautiful, healthy babies everywhere being pushed around by their spritely mothers, all in their twenties and no nanny in sight. My boarder-turned-friend was one of these mothers. At 24, only a few months older than I, she had a beautiful one-year-old boy named Joi (pronounced Yo-ee). Healthy as could be and the joy of her life, Joi was unexpected and was not exactly prepared for by two “grown-ups”. But on this little island in the arctic, when a kid comes, it is welcomed into a society that has made it easy to be a parent. Read More


Gary and Tony Have a Baby!

Alana S. 06.23.2010 10:06 PM

CNN is doing a documentary on one gay couple’s journey to have a family using donor eggs and surrogacy. It airs tomorrow night at 8 pm EST. The teaser lays down a history of Gary and Tony’s twenty-year-strong bond. The two men are committed. They are likable. They appear to be great candidates for fatherhood.

The only problem is… neither of them have a functioning uterus. Or eggs. But that’s not a problem a little cash can’t fix. Read More


Unfaithful: Stories of Betrayal.

Alana S. 06.21.2010 8:29 PM

Watching TV for the first time in ages. On Discovery Health network there is a show called Unfaithful: Stories of Betrayal.

It begins with a woman and her husband. Upon giving birth to her first child, it is immediately discovered in the delivery room that the child was not her husbands (a multi-racial child was born). The husband, Lee Chen, speaks to the camera, his face hidden behind a shadow, his voice disguised using special software. The husband mourns his wife’s infidelity and expresses guilt that he isn’t able to love a child that is not his.

The couples counselor:

I’ve only [counseled] one couple who kept the child fathered in an affair…. They are still having problems. It’s very hard to see the characteristics, the facial features, the behaviors that belong to somebody else in your child. It’s difficult, very very difficult. I would say adoption is the best way to go in that situation.

-David Carder- Family Therapist

They gave the child up for open adoption. Lee was painfully honest about his inability to correctly and fully love a child that wasn’t his.

I know how it is Lee. It’s awkward trying to lie to yourself about who is in your family.


Changesurfer Interview

Alana S. 06.20.2010 7:57 AM

Had a talk with James Hughes from changesurfer radio on My Daddy’s Name Is Donor.


Damage by Design

Alana S. 06.18.2010 11:49 AM

Polly was a commentator on a former blog post, she writes:

As an older adoptee who grew up in ignorance of my adoptive status; discovered my adoption at 17 (my gut instincts led me to the truth)….and found my first mother at 25 (against all odds at a time when anonymity ruled); I can only applaud openness and honesty for DC children/adults.

At the time of my adoption (1945) it was widely accepted practice that a physical/emotional/legal disconnection from genealogical parents and kin was justified. This argument cannot be sustained in DC practices in the 21st century.

Open adoptions have been practised since the early 1980s. They are undoubtedly a “softer” experience of adoption for most people. However, open adoption does not take away the trauma of adoption; and I do not imagine that “openness” in DC practices will either.

No one would EVER intentionally create a child to be an adoptee; either in a traditional closed adoption or a more open adoption.

The most damaging aspect of DC; is that the child is created with the deliberate intention of being separated from his/her genealogical mother, father and kin. It happens by DESIGN, not by default.

It is this deliberate intent that is, as I see it, the core wrong of donor conception practices.


Solidarity. Gay Pride Month.

Alana S. 06.17.2010 7:15 AM

I was busking in the subway last week when a beautiful man approached me, praised my vocals, and bought a CD. I’ve since corresponded with him  and as it turns out he is a successful vlogger on Gay Rights issues. His name is John Smith and he reminded me this week about what is at stake and why its so important for us to be delicate in our stances.

He was enthusiastic enough about my music that he incorporated one of my songs into his latest vlog.

He chose this song as the anthem for his Gay Pride Month vlog, which was especially poetic considering I had written “So Be Glad” in honor of my child born through egg donation. The Lyrics:

I’m not allowed to fall in love
I’m not allowed to be caressed and kissed and hugged
For if I do it might take away my soul
For if I do I may degrade to play the pretty girls’ role

So imagine a set of sheets without a lover’s scent
and a body that is stiff, uptight, and ready to repent
and be thankful for your partner who supports what you do
and just know that there are those who don’t have love like you do Read More


The Only Quote We Need…

Alana S. 06.15.2010 8:08 PM

There is one section of “My Daddy’s Name Is Donor” that hit me hard. Under “Is There a Right to a Child?” Christine Whipp shared:

There is a legal and moral right not to be prevented from indulging in natural procreation, which is framed in various Human Rights conventions. There is no societal right to purloin a child belonging to somebody else, or to expect society to provide a child for somebody who wishes to be a parent.

Page 68 of the report, underneath Christine, Joanna Rose is quoted as:

There is the right to try to have a child naturally within your own sexual relationships… but not a right to have the genetic child of another [person] outside your sexual relationships, facilitated by artificial means.”


Happy Seed Provider’s Day, Dad

Alana S. 06.15.2010 5:50 PM

A co-worker at the coffee shop I work at approached me yesterday wanting to know if I could cover Sunday for him so he can spend the day with his dad for father’s day. “No problem,” I said. “I don’t have a real dad anyways.”

He gave me a funny look. “Oh, I’m sorry,” he said. I chuckled uncomfortably and replied, “Don’t worry- it’s not a big deal…. Have fun!”

I recently did an email interview with Barbara Kay from Canada’s National Post. She calls me the”poster child for the negative fallout from the commodification of human genetic materials.” I’m also a “20-something college dropout… obsessed with her genetic heritage, to which she attributes substance abuse and intimacy issues.” Read More


Your legal responsibilities as a sperm, egg, or embryo donor

Alana S. 06.14.2010 4:10 PM

Just checking out the HFEA’s site and reading some of their literature:

“If you plan to donate outside a licensed clinic… we recommend you consult a solicitor first. Where fresh donated sperm is used outside of an HFEA licensed clinic, the donor is considered by law to be the child’s legal father, with all the responsibilities and rights that involves.”

I read it like this: Because we’re adults and we drew up this fancy notarized paper-work saying that this guy isn’t your real father (or mother), you have no legal or spiritual right to claim him/her as such.

And for parents, consider it like this: Because we are a billion dollar industry, and we essentially own fertility lawyers with their million dollar salaries, you have to pay us $$ to legitimize your donor conception, otherwise your “donor” might come knocking on your door asking for their kid back. Suckers.

And notice how father and “second parent” are almost synonymous- an etymological slippery slope, degrading the importance of fatherhood.

The child’s father/second parent

Where the woman who gives birth is married, her husband will be presumed to be the legal father of the child, unless it can be shown that he did not consent to the embryo being placed in his wife. Read More


Inigo Montoya and the Quest for Justice

Alana S. 06.10.2010 12:19 PM

For all of you who think Donor Kids just need to go to the beach more often to be happy:

This is what’s up.


Akusala in the Culture. A Letter to Parents.

Alana S. 06.09.2010 4:41 PM

To parents who have already used commercial conception:

I am 23 years old and being rushed into answering some of life’s biggest problems. If you promise to be patient, I’ll do my best to answer. Though I expect it will take a lifetime…

Buddhism teaches us that all life is suffering. The world is not separated into good and evil, heaven and hell, Jesus and Lucifer. In Buddhism, the world is Kusala and Akusala. Kusala can be explained in many ways. Intelligence, justice, skill, health, talent, happiness, joy, generosity, kindness, empathy, love… These all fall under the category of Kusala. Akusala on the other hand, is everything opposite: lethargy, ignorance, humiliation, degradation, injustice, pain, dishonesty, deception, sickness… Read More